2007

John Greco - Third-team All-America, Rivals.com
Brett Kern - Third-team All-America, AP; Third-team All-America, Rivals.com

2004

Bruce Gradkowski - Honorable mention All-America, SportsIllustrated.com
Lance Moore - Honorable mention All-America, SportsIllustrated.com

2001

Chester Taylor - Second-team All-America, ABC Sports Online; Third-team All-America, AP; Fourth-team All-America, Sporting News; Honorable mention All-America, CNN/SI

2000

DeJuan Goulde - Third-team All-America, Football News
Chester Taylor - Honorable mention All-America, Football News

1999

Colin Westrich - Third-team All-America, Sporting News

1995

Wasean Tait - Third-team All-America, AP; Second-team All-America, UPI
Steve Rosi - Honorable mention All America, UPI

1986

Harold McGuire - Third-team All-America, AP

1982

Tony Lee - Honorable mention All-America, AP

1981

Mike Kennedy - Second-team All-America, NEA

1975

Gene Swick - First-team All-America, UPI; Third-team All-America, AP; Finished 10th in the Heisman Trophy voting

1971

Chuck Ealey - First-team All-America, Football News; Second-team All-America, UPI; Third-team All-America, AP; Finished eighth in the Heisman Trophy voting

1971

Mel Long - First-team All-America, AP; First-team All- America, UPI; First-team All-America, NEA; First-team All-America, FWAA

1970

Mel Long - First-team All-America, NEA; Second-team All-America, AP; Third-team All-America, Central Press

1969

Curtis Johnson - First-team All-America, NEA; Second-team All-America, AP; Second-team All-America, Central Press

1967

Tom Beutler - First-team All-America, Central Press; Second-team All-America, NEA

1947

Myron Carman - Second-team All-America, Williamson

1938

Dan Bukovich - First-team All-America, AP